WWW.LGBTQNATION.COM
Nancy Mace & Sarah McBride show that the biggest fights are still to come
Noted anti-trans Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC) lost the Republican primary for South Carolina governor in a truly decisive defeat, coming in fifth place. But the pain and policy that she has brought with her rhetoric still remains and can’t be expected to go out the door with her when she leaves Congress in January. We should certainly enjoy Rep. Sarah McBride’s (D-DE) quips about her co-worker’s loss, but there needs to be a fight to restore and improve situations when we have power again. There’s something comforting in seeing Mace burn her entire political career to the ground while embracing the anti-trans platform to an extreme degree. An anti-trans attack has never been far from her lips, including when questioning Gov. Tim Walz (D) about welfare fraud or responding to Trump’s calls for genocide. As her obsession controlled her actions, she claimed to have no friends and clearly alienated the Republican base, even in her home state. Related Governor’s races have never been more important for trans rights than this year There were rumors last year that Mace might try to bow out rather than face another election, following the tactic of her fellow anti-trans Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene. Instead, she’s faced a humiliating defeat. That feels like it should be a warning to other politicians who have been voted in to support their constituents, but instead spent their time obsessing over trans people and genitalia. But while Mace lost favor with voters and other Republicans in Congress, the criticism she has faced publicly has not been about her anti-trans crusade, demonstrating their willingness to accept the anti-trans platform. Instead, former House Speaker Kevin McCarthy called her one of the “least ethical” and “least respected” members of Congress and went on Fox News to say he hopes she gets “the help she needs.”South Carolina’s Attorney General Alan Wilson called her “an entitled spoiled brat.” And earlier this year, Mace’s own former staffers said she should leave electoral politics and that she was “one of the worst people I’ve ever met.” Dive deeper every day Join our newsletter for thought-provoking commentary that goes beyond the surface of LGBTQ+ issues Subscribe to our Newsletter today While her obsession with trans people might have sparked some of those comments, her party never raised it as a problem. Instead, they relayed anecdotes about requests to bring her liquor, do her housework, and boost her standing in Reddit forums about the “hottest women in Congress.” At the other end of the political and personality spectra is McBride, the Delaware representative who is the first openly trans member of Congress, but who campaigned on family and household issues and worked to avoid being seen as a trans rights candidate purely because of her own gender identity. Mace and her cohort made it clear to everyone early on that ignoring their anti-trans campaign wasn’t going to be viable, and McBride was criticized for not opposing the Capitol bathroom ban introduced by House Speaker Mike Johnson under pressure from Mace. As Mace and McBride continued to face off, McBride clearly started to realize the need to fight back and came a long way. A year and a half in, McBride has come out swinging with social media videos and call-outs of Republicans in front of Congress, while still reaching across the aisle to make deals with Republicans for trans rights. Now her response to Mace’s loss has been pitch-perfect put-downs, calling Mace “Congress’s top bathroom sheriff.” thoughts and prayers https://t.co/NHCCE0DiI0— Sarah McBride (@SarahEMcBride) June 10, 2026 But at the same time, Mace has still claimed a victory of sorts through her rampant transphobia. McBride has had to spend time, money, and energy fighting back against Mace and her Congress-level anti-trans propaganda, rather than devoting her full attention to representing her constituents in the way that she had originally hoped and that politicians are actually supposed to (although it can be easy to forget that that’s their jobs at times). Not only have Congressional Republicans not pushed back on Mace’s transphobia while happily criticizing the South Carolina representative, but under the current president, they have been happy to adopt some version of it into their work. Speaker Johnson’s willingness to bring forward the Capitol bathroom ban was an early sign of that willingness. So, while the zingers from McBride are lovely to see, they’re only a part of what we have ahead of us. If the Democrats retake the House in the fall and end Johnson’s speakership, there are things like the Capitol bathroom ban that could be overturned for a nice little success that would benefit not only McBride but also plenty of staffers and other people who visit the Capitol every day. And that win might be easier to enact without shouts from Mace and Greene about trans people, although Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-CO) will likely still be there. But it will still face Republican noise, and it will be only one small fight in a much larger battle. We have years ahead of the president and his cronies doing all they can to attack trans people in an effort to eradicate us and distract everyone from the very real problems that face Americans. Mace and McBride have become part of a culture war that is pulling focus from addressing the real struggles. It’s no wonder that the people of South Carolina didn’t want to elect Mace to lead their government when she has spent the last two years working on attacking a marginalized community that doesn’t affect most people in the state. But that same problem could also trip up McBride and other Democrats: while McBride isn’t facing a primary challenger at the moment, she’s been in headlines for her responses to transphobes. Successes for her state have been less publicized. That sort of thing, initiated by the Republicans, fuels their own propaganda that Democrats just want to talk about trans people when the reality is the inverse. Mace is headed for the door, but if Democrats take power, we’ll need to fight for more than getting our rights back. We also have to work on improving the country from where it was before, from trans rights to wider issues of inequality. One thing former Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg said, which received a mixed reaction, is that the goal for 2028 shouldn’t be to put things back to the way they were in 2024: they weren’t right then, and that’s part of why the GOP took power. We’ll need to work to build something better. Congress in 2026 shouldn’t be working to overturn bathroom bans installed by the Republicans, but rather to enshrine trans rights within the Capitol’s Congressional Rules: that approach needs to be applied across the board. Good on McBride for the putdowns, though; they gave us all a much-needed laugh. Subscribe to the LGBTQ Nation newsletter and be the first to know about the latest headlines shaping LGBTQ+ communities worldwide.
0 Комментарии
0 Поделились
24 Просмотры
0 предпросмотр